“I Prefer MY BRAIN”: AI Haters Are Sharing How They Subtly Shame People Who Rely On ChatGPT To Think For Them, And I’m Going To Start Doing This

    “I think there’s a perceived acceptability when we pretend we need these things. We don’t, and they’re making you LESS.”

    It seems like any time I try to do anything on my phone or computer these days, there's a new AI feature I didn't ask for (that often doesn't even do what it says it does). My least favorite of all of them has got to be the "helpful" overview that pops up whenever I google something, like this:

    Search shows a question about fraction comparison, stating 5/16 is larger than 3/8, with a detailed explanation

    Well, over the weekend, I read a great book that helped me understand why AI is being shoved down all of our throats and what to make of the never-ending hype around it. It's called The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI: How to Think About Artificial Intelligence—Before It's Too Late.

    Book cover titled "The Reverse Centaur's Guide to Life After AI" by Cory Doctorow, discussing AI's impact

    One of my big takeaways is that while there are certain tasks AI can be useful for, the pressure to use it for everything is part of a hype cycle that's inflating an economic bubble and eroding our skills, in addition to its environmental harms. So, when I came across this post on Threads where user @rachelmercy shared that she's started "gently shaming" people who use AI, my interest was piqued.

    Summary: The poster expresses disapproval of people using AI, sharing an anecdote about a student using AI to improve schoolwork, and emphasizing the importance of using one's own brain

    Naturally, people started sharing their go-to responses to the dreaded AI question, and I'm really loving this energy. Here's what they had to say:

    1. Some people shared their favorite snappy comebacks:

    Social media post: "When people ask if you use AI, say, 'Of course not. I'm neither stupid nor lazy, so why would I do that?'"

    2. "i prefer to be a first hand thinker as opposed to a second hand one."

    Social media post featuring a profile image and the text: "Do you use AI? No, I prefer to be a first-hand thinker as opposed to a second-hand one."

    3. "Got all my degrees with a blue book and a pencil."

    Summary of a comment criticizing professionals for their lack of expertise, emphasizing the importance of deep knowledge over superficial skills

    4. But some people really held nothing back:

    Comment from spookyghostslair expressing disdain for AI users, preferring to walk away instead

    5. One person shared that they like to tell "AI horror stories" in response to people hyping it up:

    A person shares a conversation about AI and its impact on artists, ending with a humorous anecdote about AI-generated content

    6. But others advocated for a more gentle approach, like this person who urged, "create stigma at a societal level and care for those at a personal level."

    Text post about influencing people in real life, advocating harm reduction and societal stigma while caring for individuals personally

    7. "I tell people they are too smart to use AI."

    Comment by brookelinville: "I tell people they are too smart to use AI. They would much rather agree that they are smart than that we are!!"

    8. And others pointed out that using AI to do your homework just might be worse than not doing your homework at all.

    Comment criticizing the use of AI for imitation, warning against contributing to its development due to negative outcomes

    9. Many people also chimed in to talk about how AI is showing up in their profession:

    Summary of a post discussing how an author's husband reacts to assumptions that she uses AI for writing, and the perceived undervaluing of writing skills

    10. "I think there's a perceived acceptability when we pretend we need these things. We don't, and they're making you LESS."

    Comment by bubba_jung discussing zero AI usage in their animation career, urging against adopting AI, and stating it diminishes artists

    11. This person "accidentally shaded" their boss when they explained their own preference for avoiding AI:

    A person discusses unintentionally shading their boss over his use of GenAI, highlighting cognitive decline concerns with such technology

    12. Others shared conversations they've had with coworkers:

    A person's comment about a coworker dismissing "anti-AI hype" and their claim that generative AI steals from artists, followed by no response

    13. This one made me heave a big sigh:

    Social media post: A person is impressed by a puzzle but their teammate suggests it was made with AI, highlighting differing views on AI's role in creativity

    14. "I prefer MY BRAIN."

    A high school teacher in Spain shares their preference for using their own brain over AI tools, describing a training experience with chat platforms

    15. In conclusion, please write your own dumb email! I'd rather see your real human typos and actual thoughts than read "It's not this, it's that."

    Social media post humorously comparing people who use AI to write emails with those who don't return shopping carts

    What do you think about this? Let me know in the comments!

    Comments